Nature girl's picture

Lonely Knot

Observed: 29th January 2011 By: Nature girl
Royal Society for the Protection of Birds
Nature girl’s reputation in BirdsNature girl’s reputation in BirdsNature girl’s reputation in Birds
IMG_4829
IMG_4822
IMG_4824
Description:
Identifications
Species interactions

No interactions present.

Species with which Knot (Calidris canutus) interacts

Comments

bobthebirder's picture

knot or dunlin

Very difficult without seeing the full bill, but the barring on the flanks strongly suggests knot rather than dunlin. Perhaps Nature girl has a photo showing the bill in its entirety.

Bob Ford

ophrys's picture

Knot?

It may well be a Knot...my ID was made fairly hastily upon looking at the apparently very dark legs.

Looking again, the bill does seem quite short...

Interesting how such essentially different species can sometimes appear so similar.

Ian
_________________

My Flickr photos...

http://www.flickr.com/photos/52163027@N02/

Nature girl's picture

Yes sorry, they're not very

Yes sorry, they're not very good pictures. Luckily I've discovered one in my Recycle Bin showing the whole bill, which should clear up this confusion! I'll add it on.

lordro's picture

Nature- Girl's Knot (or Dunlin)

The Eye-stripe suggests "Knot"-(RSPB Birds by Name site)

bobthebirder's picture

knot a dunlin

The new photo confirms it - the bird is a knot. A dunlin would have a noticeably longer bill, slightly down-curved near the tip. Dunlins are also far smaller than knot, but a lone bird is difficult to size.

Bob Ford